In a comprehensive and robust legal response submitted to the National Congress, Minister of Justice Fernando Rabat firmly rejected the constitutional accusation brought forward by opposition lawmakers. Through his defense counsel, Juan Ignacio Piña, the minister systematically dismantled the three chapters of the libel, asserting that all administrative decisions and sentence interpretations strictly adhered to existing laws and aligned with established Supreme Court jurisprudence.
The high-stakes political proceeding centers on contentious allegations regarding sentence reductions granted to individuals convicted of specific crimes, questions of administrative probity, and the transparency of information provided to the legislative branch. However, the defense contends that the political maneuver oversteps legal boundaries, emphasizing that policy disagreements cannot be weaponized as constitutional infractions.
Defending Legal Consistency and Supreme Court Precedents
Addressing the core of the opposition's claims, Rabat’s defense emphasized that a constitutional accusation cannot and should not serve as a "vote of censure" meant to penalize differences in legal interpretation. The document outlines that the constitutional grounds invoked by lawmakers are strictly taxative and demand direct, personal culpability rather than ideological disagreements over ministerial decisions.
Regarding the scrutiny over sentence adjustments, the legal filing highlights that existing legislative frameworks at the time did not explicitly outline retroactive exclusions or restrictions for specific historical cases. The defense maintained that executive authorities cannot arbitrarily impose administrative limitations that fall strictly within the purview of the legislative branch, reinforcing that all applied criteria closely followed Supreme Court precedents.
Institutional Transparency and Moving Forward
While fiercely defending the legality of his administrative acts, the minister acknowledged procedural shortcomings, particularly concerning victim notification and participation frameworks in certain judicial processes. Rabat noted that these institutional gaps are serious matters that the government is actively working to correct through broader, structural regulatory reforms rather than ad-hoc penalties.
Furthermore, the defense dismissed allegations regarding a lack of probity or intentional misinformation before parliament, clarifying that legal deductions derived from accurate normative premises do not constitute falsehoods. As the political debate moves forward within national legislative committees, the administration maintains that the accusations amount to political disagreements rather than verifiable breaches of the constitution or penal law.